Cases
Significant Representative Matters: Defense verdict in lawsuit filed against a major, nationally recognized retail chain alleging both intentional torts
negligence. Client was entitled to recover attorneys' fees
costs based on issuance of Proposal for Settlement/Offer of Judgment.
Favorable verdict in motor vehicle accident trial in which client admitted negligence in the operation of a motor vehicle. Verdict was favorable in that jury awarded far less than what client had previously offered plaintiff at mediation.
Dismissal of premises liability case after deposition of third party plaintiff. Upon careful interrogation of claimant, it was revealed during the deposition that the documents offered in support of the claim were not what they were purported to be.
Apartment complex owner defense: An invitee fell down a flight of concrete steps breaking bones
incurring substantial medical bills. She brought suit against the apartment complex to recover her damages. Witnesses that came to the plaintiff's aid immediately after the fall inspected the stairs
found nothing that would have caused the fall. Additionally, during her deposition testimony the plaintiff was unclear as to what she believed caused her to fall. Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment was granted, with the defendant entitled to recover fees
costs.
Retailer subrogation defense: Plaintiff insurer alleged that defective installation of a dryer caused a fire that destroyed an entire floor of an apartment complex. After paying its insured based on its contract of insurance, the insurer then filed a subrogation suit against the retail merchant. The jury returned a defense verdict in favor of the retail merchant. Defendant entitled to recover costs.
Apartment complex owner negligent security/wrongful death defense: A 21-year-old apartment complex tenant was shot
killed during the night while in the playground area of the apartment complex. The assailant was never identified
the crime remained unsolved. He was survived by his parents
3-year-old daughter. Lawyers for the estate made a dem
in the amount of $9,000,000.00. The jury found the defendant liable for not having any security measures in place but also found the decedent to be 68 percent liable for his own death. The jury award to the estate was $333,000.00. The estate's appeal was unsuccessful.
Insurance company uninsured/under-insured motorists defense: Plaintiff filed an under-insured motorists claim against his insurer based on auto accident. He had already received the policy limits from the other driver's insurance policy
sought to benefit from his UM policy. The jury agreed that the accident in question was the plaintiff's fault
rendered a defense verdict in favor of the plaintiff's insurance company.
Grocer defense: Plaintiff filed suit alleging that he slipped
fell in liquid that was left unattended on defendant's floor. The plaintiff had multi-level lower back surgery. Plaintiff's key witness was a friend who was less than credible. Under cross-examination the plaintiff's
his key witness's stories diverged. The jury found in favor of the defendant. Defendant entitled to recover fees
costs.
Corporate defendant in rear-end auto accident: Corporate defendant fleet vehicle approached intersection wherein the traffic light was red for his lane. The fleet vehicle was second in line. The light turned green. The plaintiff who was in the vehicle just ahead of the corporate defendant's vehicle began to go
then abruptly stopped. The fleet vehicle rear-ended the plaintiff's vehicle. In the 2 years to follow, the plaintiff had three surgeries (TMJ, knee
shoulder) all allegedly due to the rear end collision. Defendant stipulated to liability
challenged causation. Defense verdict with defendant entitled to recover fees
costs due to offer of judgment.
Retail merchant slip
fall: Plaintiff alleged that the floor was wet with liquid which caused her to slip
fall incurring an injury requiring surgery. Her key witness was her adult son who was with her when the alleged incident occurred. Despite giving deposition testimony favorable to his mother's case, at trial on cross-examination he admitted that when he inspected the floor immediately after the alleged fall, he saw nothing that would have caused her to fall. Defense verdict with defendant entitled to recover fees
costs.
Retail merchant defense: Plaintiff alleged that his 2-year-old child suffered a fractured femur while inside defendant's store. The child's leg was broken due to heavy unsecured merch
ise falling on his leg when he disturbed it. The jury found plaintiff/child's father 65 percent negligent for his lack of supervision of the child. Defendant entitled to recover fees based on offer of judgment.
Liquor merchant slip
fall: Plaintiff patron enters liquor store out of the rain. She walked across the entire wet parking lot into the store
slipped
fell as she went to make a turn down an aisle. Defendant stipulated to the absence of a wet floor sign - jury found 65 percent negligence on plaintiff
appeal by plaintiff unsuccessful.
Car dealership defense/auto accident: Defendant auto dealer's employee took a newly purchased vehicle across the street to get the tank filled for the new owner. On his way back from the gas station, the employee attempted to make a right turn on a one-way street. He did not see the plaintiff riding a bicycle on the sidewalk coming from the opposite direction of the traffic on the one-way street. 70% liability attributed to the bicycle riding plaintiff. Defendant entitled to recover fees based on offer of judgment.
Retail Merchant Assault
Battery, Invasion of Privacy, Defamation: Plaintiff alleged that her privacy was invaded by defendant's employee when the employee physically assaulted her
strewn her lingerie across the parking lot of its business. Plaintiff claimed that the employee used racial epithets against her in the course of the physical
very public assault. Defense verdict. Defendant entitled to fees
costs.
Published Works: Negligent Security Claims In Florida: the Victim-Targeted Defense, Defense Digest, Vol. 23, No. 1, March 2017
Florida's Proposals for Settlement in Dangerous Instrumentality Cases, Defense Digest, Vol. 16, No. 2, June 2010
